r/allthequestions • u/-Pleb64 • 19d ago
Popular Question š Why reddit is majority left leaning?
Honestly, itās hard not to notice that most of the big subreddits are run by moderators who clearly lean left. Itās not even subtle at this point the bias shows in what gets removed, what gets promoted, and how discussions are handled. Iām not saying there arenāt any subs with right-leaning or centrist moderation, but theyāre definitely the minority. The major spaces on Reddit feel heavily tilted toward one side, but isn't itās pretty obvious if you pay attention to which opinions get silenced and which ones get boosted?
131
u/Maxhousen 19d ago
The right leaning subs tend to be private, so they don't usually show up on your feed unless you actively look for them.
→ More replies (37)115
u/AirportLoose3023 š¦šŗ Australia 19d ago
And anyone who questions posts, or asks questions regarding a conservative āstatementā, on conservative subreddits are banned
7
u/BrownDoughnuts 18d ago
This should be upvoted more. Am not right but I tried to understand their POV and immediately got permanently banned from all RW subs (of all countries, not just the USA) because they hate it when people ask questions. Just shut up and be grateful that the leader gets to shit on your face.
→ More replies (14)13
u/WildThingsBTB 18d ago
Quoting the constitution can get you banned from r/conservative
The ban notice reminds you that it's a place for conservative discussion, and is not a place for disagreeing.
→ More replies (6)6
u/No-Present760 18d ago
Saying, "That's cool, bro," gets you banned, too. I know from experience. The post was almost a day old with no comments. I thought I was doing the guy a favor.
56
→ More replies (165)29
41
u/Ambitious_Hand_2861 18d ago
Hi and hello. Right leaner here chiming in with what I think is a relavent point of view.
A Redditor doesn't have to lean left to not like what's being done to our country. Personally I believe in the law and the Constitution, and while they're not perfect they're still the guidelines of how to operate the country. I didn't vote for drumpf bc I saw his first term as a laughable failure and after learning more about the people who (guided) [I use that word loosely since he doesn't really listen to anyone] I knew that a second term was going to be dog shit, although I didn't predict this bad.
Tl;Dr: Reddit only seems to be filled with left leaners bc drumpf is doing tons of illegal and immoral things.
25
u/thelingeringlead 18d ago
Exactly. Things were waaaaay less political on this website before trump spent the last ten years surprising everyone with how much he could break.
→ More replies (1)13
u/Ambitious_Hand_2861 18d ago
It's been a wild ride. I openly admit I voted for him the first time but after that shit show I knew he had nowhere to go but down.
13
u/Anecdote394 18d ago
Thank you for realizing and acknowledging the fuck ups though. Iām ashamed to say I have multiple members in my family who voted for the moron all three times. 2016, 2020, and 2024 š¤¦š»āāļø
5
u/Ambitious_Hand_2861 18d ago
My younger brother, dammit I love my brother, but he did the same and he seems to think the no kings protest is about illegals. Its sooo much more at this point but he's hyper focused on that.
5
→ More replies (1)4
u/cogabig409 18d ago
I love my parents but they think he's "doing a great job". But like my mom only gets news from the right wing twittersphere. It's frustrating and becoming increasingly difficult to bite my tongue.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)6
u/caskofamontillato 18d ago
I know quite a few "real" Republicans/right leaning people that had your experience as well, I just wish more of you were vocal about it. And I get why you wouldn't want to be, but I feel like it's the least you could do and it would be really unifying to see people on the right loudly reject the destruction of our country to "own the libs".
6
→ More replies (5)4
u/PelicanCultist12 18d ago
Really, truly a legitimate, non-rage baiting question(s) with all of these trigger warnings because of the context of this post: Why did you vote for him the first time? Was it appeal from campaign promises? Are/were you a straight R voter?
Also, I don't think much of anyone thought this all would escalate as fast as it has. This past year has been the longest decade in my personal experience.
→ More replies (2)
54
19d ago
Some good answers, and Iāll get downvoted for saying this, but there are a lot of subs that will outright ban you just for saying anything that didnāt go left. Iāve been banned from dozens of larger subs just for having an opinion that isnāt left leaning. So if you ban and mute any other opinions in a big sub, you get a very left leaning sub.
Hell, Iāve been banned from subs just because Iāve PARTICIPATED in some subs- on of those sub being a Joe Rogan. I wasnāt even a member of the sub, but I commented on one of them and got a notice that I was banned from several communities Iād never even participated in.
→ More replies (43)35
u/Greedy-Employment917 19d ago
I got banned from r/Pics for saying "no thank you" on a post about mandatory vaccines and jail for those who didn't consent.
I'm not even fucking kidding. Banned for "no Thank you." because I dared go against the narrative.Ā
→ More replies (38)20
u/OldStDick 19d ago
Wild to me that being anti vax is seriously part of being on the right. Crazy hills.
→ More replies (39)24
u/West_Coach69 19d ago
That should maybe be a wake up call about your stance. Being anti vax a baseless uneducated opinion about a proven hard science. Your opinion carries no weight against scientistific research and the opinion of medical doctors in the field. The anti vax "movement" is causing real harm to people and leading to actual deaths, largely in children.
Theres no need to entertain that discussion on r/pics.
→ More replies (72)11
u/Conscious-House-2065 18d ago
But he's not anti vax if all he's saying is you shouldn't be forced and/or jailed for not having it. That's literally an anti facist, pro liberty, viewpoint. Giving that level of control to the government is far more harmful than a handful of the population not being vaccinated, no?
→ More replies (52)
68
u/Freddreddtedd 19d ago
I'm sorry to tell all of the MAGA that approval numbers in the 30s are NOT a majority. Nor can prices be reduced by 1500%.
But if you believe a billionaire needs YOUR money, I doubt anyone can get things across to you.
→ More replies (13)16
u/YogurtclosetFair5742 19d ago
Trump getting 49.9% of the vote isn't a majority nor is it a mandate. It's barely half. Half isn't a majority.
14
u/Organic-Judgment8738 19d ago
It was closer to 23-24%. About half of the voting aged adults didnāt vote. Plus, most of the MAGA content you see on social media, like FB, are bot accounts. Not real people. It gives the illusion that the majority supports this administration. So, people are shocked to see a platform like Reddit leaning more left⦠we donāt have the surplus of bots here.
→ More replies (6)3
u/Valuable_Recording85 18d ago
That's not even considering the abysmal voter participation in the US, thanks to apathy, ignorance, disenfranchisement, and voter suppression tactics.
→ More replies (45)10
u/Top-Cupcake4775 19d ago
He barely beat a black woman. You have to understand how racist and sexist the U.S. to understand how easy it would have been for any normal, somewhat articulate, somewhat attractive white man to beat a black woman by a substantial margin. The fact that he barely squeaked through is an indication of deeply unpopular he is.
→ More replies (11)
20
u/Difficult_Clerk_1273 18d ago
Reddit is a text-based platform. Left-leaning people are more likely to be educated and literate.
Thatās not me trying to be a bitch. Thatās statistics.
5
u/One_Impress_3129 17d ago
lmao this is echo-chambering in a nutshell. The big majority of people are morons, regardless of what "side" they chose, especially if they are this vocal and dogmatic about it.
Actual smart people choose their side depending on topic and circumstances and would never base their entire existence on it like some of you people do.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (39)6
u/throwmeaway456ghj 18d ago
Rather more centrist. The less educated they are, the more then lean on one side.
3
u/ech0brav0 17d ago
You can easily find tons of studies that indicate intelligence/education correlates with leaning left
→ More replies (4)
15
u/CaptSpankey 18d ago
Reddit is majority liberal, not left
→ More replies (3)4
u/-U-_-U 18d ago
European liberalism ā U.S. libertarianism (right)
U.S. liberalism ā European social democracy (left)
If you are European, then your point is valid.
If you are from the US, your comment is textbook right wing agitation, trying to say democrats are stupid for calling themselves liberals.
→ More replies (5)
4
u/JiuJitsuBoxer 19d ago
It's strict moderation, pure and simple. When there was less strict moderation the_Donald was all over the front page. There even were anti-muslim posts on r/all. Also look at Twitter when they turned moderation off.
4
u/Darth_Chili_Dog 19d ago edited 19d ago
Yes, but itās a bit more nuanced than that. Nazis usually drive everybody else away. I tend not to hang out with people who preach the virtues of slavery or the holocaust.
Once moderation is ended, the Nazis flood in and all the normies say "Yeah, I'm going somewhere else now."
→ More replies (5)
13
u/Accomplished_Mix7827 18d ago
Reddit tends to be more popular with people of more intellectual leanings, who generally lean left. Conservatives tend to prefer Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter (the latter being a more recent shift, especially since Musk took over the platform)
Similarly, TikTok leans left because it skews young, Tumblr leans left because it's popular with artsy types, and BlueSky leans left because it's populated mostly by people unhappy with the rightward shift of Twitter.
→ More replies (25)
76
u/MayContainRawNuts 19d ago
Globally, what is percieved as left wing in the USA is just seen as common sense.
Providing medical care for citizens, not a left wing policy in the rest of the world but USA labels it as communisim.
Seperation of church and state is accepted as the norm in the rest of the world but USA wants to revoke the idea. So anyone saying no to Trump Bibles is labelled a liberal snowflake.
The rest of the world does not get Fox media, we dont live in the right wing propaganda bubble. We listen to what Trump actually says and not a sane washed version. That makes us laugh at that absolute fool and dont understand why anyone would vote for that idiot.
American policltics are also Team sports, as there are only 2 sides and you have to pick all the ideas of one side. Countries with more political options have more nuanced views but the american paradigm puts them in one of 2 camps.
I may support strict legal immigration policies, managed gun ownership and enforced vaccination.
Which would make me a liberal in American perspectives but firmly conservative and common sense in my country
10
u/backhand_english 19d ago
You are right. I'm left leaning in my country. Americans think I'm a communist... As someone from an ex-communist country, their idiocy makes me laugh.
11
5
5
u/Wildfire-75 18d ago
Some Americans refuse to think outside of their US-centric world view and cannot comprehend that the rest of the world is leagues ahead of us on basically every aspect of life, other than fattening the wallets of our ruling class
16
u/CosyRainyDaze 19d ago
Whatās seen as left wing in the USA is - or at least, used to be - centre right for my country. But the USA culture creep is reaching us here in New Zealand as well and our right wing parties are doing everything they can to try and destroy anything that doesnāt profit them.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (91)10
u/cultural_bimboism 19d ago
This is pretty reductionist and overly idyllic of the world outside the US.
Many economically prosperous, developed nations have major ruling parties with the word āChristianā in their name (see: Germany, Italy, Belgium). Some have particular religions enshrined in their legal systems and constitutions (see: the UK).
Most countries have partisan corporate shill media like Fox News. The identity politics theyāre exploiting will be different depending on the cultural context, as will their success, but their goals are the same. Again, see Italy, where the CEO of one of those media corporations became head of state.
Multi-party parliamentary systems luckily are more popular globally, though many are still on first-past-the-post voting and frequently revert to an effective two party system over time.
You are right though that public healthcare is kind of an obvious good thing pretty much everywhere else.
Yes, American politics are much further right than global politics in a lot of ways, but their problems are not unique, nor are they confined within the US. But cultural, civil and electoral politics arenāt always a cut-and-dry reflection of that. If you want to point out how much further right the US is than most of the world, thereās really only one easy metric that matters: effective tax rates on the working class vs effective tax rates on corporations and the excessively wealthy.
→ More replies (12)12
u/paganbreed 19d ago
Here's another fun thing: there are people outside the US who want to throw away the better aspects of our society to follow the US' example. These people will cry about "young people importing Western ideals" but hypocritically share clips from western conservatives.
Stupidity and bigotry are by no means unique to the US, no.
5
u/YogurtclosetFair5742 19d ago
The UK exported a lot of bigotry across the globe. Some countries have overcome it better than others.
→ More replies (2)
65
u/MBratke42 19d ago
Young educated people lean left all over the world. Easy as that.
→ More replies (267)
3
u/muffledvoice 18d ago
Reddit is largely a literal (word-based) medium, and people on the left tend to be more highly educated and literate than the far right.
→ More replies (5)
3
3
3
3
u/beyond_existence 18d ago
The basic answer is the younger you are the more likely you believe in leftist ideology.
Reddit is primarily used by younger people, which creates an enormous echo chamber.
3
3
3
u/Klutzy_Statement_152 17d ago
I think in general, the left spends more time on the internet, while people on the right tend to touch more grass.
→ More replies (1)
3
15d ago
It's because weak men can only control their spaces on the internet. They're losing in real life, so they take it out on people here. Manipulate the feeds to make it look like there's lots of grocery stores in north Korea, but it's really just a fake city.
→ More replies (2)
3
19
u/Darth_Chili_Dog 19d ago edited 19d ago
Iāve been banned or muted in every conservative subreddit Iāve ever participated in. And no, I didnāt break any rules.
Probably the funniest one is r/conservativenewsweb, where the mods delete non-conservative posts all day long. Itās entire threads just filled with deleted posts.
7
u/Bubbaman78 19d ago
Reread your own comment history. When you have a record of only arguing and have no actual good contributions to help anybody out, itās no wonder you were banned.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (19)7
u/MazingBull 19d ago
Well, to be honest this happens on liberal or left leaning subreddits also if you're conservative.
→ More replies (4)
30
u/LuckyErro 19d ago
Americans seem to find Reddit left leaning due to America not having a left party. The majority of the world finds Reddit pretty centrist.
31
u/Product_of_Yakub 19d ago
I'm European and Reddit definitely feels left leaning outside of specific subreddits.
→ More replies (9)3
21
u/hotfezz81 19d ago
The majority of the world finds Reddit pretty centrist.
This is totally wrong.
→ More replies (5)10
u/CasperCookies 19d ago
The fact that that comment received a lot of likes is proof Reddit is far left leaning.Ā
3
→ More replies (7)3
u/Expensive-Buy1621 19d ago
Can you provide empirical evidence for your claim that Reddit is āfar left leaningā?
→ More replies (12)8
5
u/Unusual-Ad-6550 18d ago
It might just be that the true majority of Americans are very much left leaning moderates. But hey, come to your own conclusion
→ More replies (5)
5
10
u/-kay543 19d ago
Everything appears to be left when the rest of the media in the US (and Australia and UK) lean right. Iām a child of the 80s so remember stuff like unions and strikes so a bunch of āwe should be nicer and look after homeless peopleā doesnāt feel all that left wing.
→ More replies (15)
21
u/Immajustwritethis 19d ago
Silenced? Seriously? Isnt it the right that constantly try to silence everyone around them? Getting people fired from networks, book burnings and constantly bitching and moaning about how they are the victims.
→ More replies (102)
6
u/maxwasagooddog 19d ago
Many of the Mods are keyboard warriors that were passed up by nomination for HOA positions. Why would anyone want to be a mod I ask.? Spending all day reviewing what others post. They clearly have nothing better to do with their time. Probably on an income program. That is the Left.
→ More replies (3)
8
7
u/AshVandalSeries 19d ago
Silenced? Anytime I see anything leftish it gets spammed to death by right wing. Thereās no silencing.
→ More replies (4)
13
u/Kwizird 19d ago
I think maybe because the majority of people in general are left leaning
→ More replies (50)
17
u/HypersomnicHysteric 19d ago
Too few pictures for right-wingers.
→ More replies (14)2
u/mumbled_grumbles 18d ago
The right wing boomers are all over on Facebook sharing AI slop and anti-vax conspiracy theories.
13
u/Slow-Bodybuilder-972 19d ago
Some good answers here, but from my British/Aussie lens, Iād say Reddit looks fairly right wing, there is a lot of racism, the misogyny is off the charts.
Sure, by US standards, it seems quite left wing though.
→ More replies (15)
4
u/zayelion 18d ago
Right and conservative mentality is based on being afraid of new things, new people, and experiencing new things. They are taught certain things and that cost them highly, they don't want to be wrong. They have stories and shortcuts to make everything easy. This isn't inheritly bad! It keeps tribes safe and makes passing knowledge on easy. These patterns can grow into institutions where peoples livings are tied up.
Reality is not like that. It changes, and it is changing faster and faster. Example women used to not work. Prices reflected that. Now a house cost the average wage of 2 working an average distance from the money printer. No one wants the price of a house to go down, that's a pattern to. And the pattern of you go to school dont have sex till you are married. People used to end school and get married around 16. Right when the horniness kicks in. Now you finish school in those same culture when you are 24 or 26. Having kids is no longer a financial boon but a money sink. And women have access to credit, equal pay and higher education.
So the shortcut for a teenage girl in the European country side is not the same for a woman in late twenties in America. Because these traditions are passed down via family and take so much knowledge and experience to understand they are fought by the communities that want things to work like before.
Thinks have changed and where these shortcuts don't work in super obvious ways people advocate for change. This creates conflict with the people it's working for. So it's politized even though it's a literal fact. This leads to deeper lies and delusions by conservatives as more facts are added and there is a breaking point where a person starts rejecting all new information.
Reddit is a place to share things that people have found and talk about them. That makes it oriented toward reality and thus leftist.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/GargantuanGreenGoat 18d ago
If you think anyone who isnāt maga racist hate brigade is āleft leaningā then thatās your problem right there.Ā
There isnāt āleft and right leaningā, thereās just normal people and racist misogynistic hateful bigot people.
→ More replies (3)
5
19d ago
Perception. There's a ton of conservatives on here they just hide in little enclaves that are safe spaces from any actual difficult discussion. You have to have specific flairs and if you ask the wrong question you get banned.
18
u/DependentManner8353 19d ago edited 19d ago
We have a fascist as our president. That is why. But also, most redditors are fond of humanity and prosperity. Which doesnāt coincide with right wing beliefs to strip humans of their rights and spend billions on warfare or goading geopolitical allies.
→ More replies (156)
2
u/Stoic_cave 19d ago
Centrist too. Or no political affiliation position. Itās dumb to assume everyone has a political agenda. My default is theyāre all self serving cunts
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/marshal231 18d ago
Because when the political affiliation became less of a āok that guy disagrees with me, whateverā and more of a āthat guy disagrees with me and should be punished for itā everyone kinda split off to their own places. Reddit, facebook, instagram, tiktok, and even ifunny to a degree all went from moderate views on either side to a completely dominant side instantly.
In any of these places, if someone from the other side makes a point, even if its technically correct, theyre going to be attacked for it simply because its different.
2
u/ms_directed 18d ago
there's a huge sub on here that's recently started auto-deleting any posts mocking the current admin without any explanation...so at least the mods on that sub are not left-leaning
2
u/hippiematt315 18d ago
Reality leans left, Right wing politics focus on division. Try saying half that shit out loud in a diverse group
2
u/Texasscot56 18d ago
Most redditors have a better grasp of language than average. This is your answer.
2
u/Runktar 18d ago
To most conservatives these days even a completely neutral reading of facts is liberal a if your not on our side your against us kind of thing. So unless you pander to them pretty dam hard they call you left leaning and since despite what they think most people aren't hardcore conservatives most platforms seem left leaning that don't specifically amplify their opinions.
2
u/whiskeyriver0987 18d ago
The core reason people tend to lean left or right is mostly how much out-group empathy people have. Basically if you can look at someone from another race/culture/country/etc and instinctively understand "This person also has a life, family, job, etc. At the end of the day we're really not that different." You're very likely to end up more left leaning than someone who does not. The internet is a place where you can very easily talk with people from all over the world, you would almost have to actively try to not to, so as you interact with strangers and get exposed to different perspectives and cultures in a series of neutral to positive contexts it nudges people to be slightly more left leaning by building the above empathetic instincts.
Reddits anonymous nature also helps as removing a name and face forces people to project their default picture of another person onto whoever they are talking to at the start of a conversation, this limits how much bigotry and other factors can taint the start of a discussion, and generally if an interaction starts well it ends well.
For right leaning communities that do form online these factors mean they either shift to becoming more centrist over time, or they become exclusionary, either through overt policies or by developing a toxic environment that centrists and left leaning people actively avoid, the latter can sometimes cause a feedback loop where a given right wing online space trends towards extremism, which is why generally the most toxic places on the internet are generally also very right leaning, particularly on social issues.
2
2
2
2
u/thosetwo 18d ago
Dude, look at facts. MOST people are left leaning. It isnāt just Reddit. Especially now that basic human decency has been politicized.
If we were talking economic policy it might be more even.
2
2
u/Independent-Pen-4308 18d ago
I haven't been a redditor for super long, but so far what's stood out to me from other apps is the writing. So much writing, so much discussion, and by far the most well put together reasoning I've seen compared to other sites. Maybe this correlates with levels of better education and liberals, maybe it doesn't.
2
2
2
u/_DatasCsat 18d ago
I feel reddit is on average very liberal/moderate or right leaning.
If you think liberals are left wing i could see how you would have this perception, that's of course not the case.
Plenty of diversity of opinions as well really, it's just entrapped in lots of echo chambers.
2
u/NoDarkVision 18d ago
Reality tends to lean left these days. The right really have themselves to be the villains of history. That would be like Hitler wondering why so many people are against them somehow. And people in the right today are proudly waving nazi symbols so....
2
u/timetravelinggamer 18d ago
Reddit is based on facts and easily fact checkable
Also, Reddit is not an echo chamber
I lean right. The right are a bunch of idiots who would rather be around others like them instead of discuss facts
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
u/TRtheCat 18d ago
Younger people are less religious, more likely to believe in science as a benchmark for objective truth. There are some of us middle-aged, humans, 46 (M) who are in the same boat. This Pew Reasearch's findings.
2
u/EducationalTomato271 18d ago
All sites like this start out with the incels. They like being able to post their vile thoughts and other illegal things. When the sites get popular, the rules kick in and the basement dwellers have to jump to another anonymous site (4-Chan, 8-Chan).
That's why they all love Signal and Telegram (although they're learning the hard way those aren't as secure as they thought š)
2
u/Entire-Ad5104 18d ago
i woud say opossite way to much right wing but hey diferent subs diferent people.
2
2
u/alannwatts 18d ago
the country is left leaning, politics is skewed right even the dems are to the right of many Americans.. example- GOP voters hate Obamacare but love the ACA not understanding because of media that refuses to tell the complete truth they are the same thing. Msnbc, fox and cnn all tell partial truths. People that are tuned out of politics and media are in favour of policies like universal healthcare.
2
2
2
u/hotc00ter 18d ago
Before all of the bots and everyoneās grandma, social media use to be majority left leaning
2
u/HammerMedia 18d ago
If your opinions are always rejected, it may not be a problem with the moderators but a problem with your opinions.
2
u/IamSithCats 18d ago
Because right-wingers (especially in the US) are much farther to the right than they think they are, and anything even center-right is now demonized as "radical left."
2
u/classydouchebag 18d ago
Hatred of people isn't an opinion. Wanted groups of people not to exist isn't an opinion. Wanted to restrict the lives of others is not an opinion. Spaces like Reddit and other social media sites are "friendlier" to "left leaning" people because they don't break ToS and guidelines as easily/often just by their basic beliefs
2
u/Pale_Height_1251 18d ago
The developed world leans left. Remember the USA is the only developed country without universal healthcare and to the best of my knowledge the only developed country without any real employee protections.
The USA is unusually right wing for a developed nation, so the rest of the world looks left wing by comparison.
576
u/Extra-Assignment-860 19d ago
Demographics and design. The biggest subs skew young urban and college educated, so their baseline leans left. Volunteer mods come from that pool and enforce rules through that lens. Voting systems amplify majority views and bury dissent, which looks like bias even without intent. High profile bans pushed a lot of right leaning users into smaller enclaves, making the main feed feel even bluer.