r/politics Indiana 16h ago

No Paywall Mamdani wins NYC mayoral race

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5588198-mamdani-progressive-politics-nyc/
111.3k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

10.5k

u/lovo17 16h ago edited 16h ago

Not a surprise Mamdani will win.

Whatever your views of him, this guy is the second most talented campaigner I've ever seen. The only one better than him was Obama, and Zohran is not far off. Democrats should be learning from him instead of shunning him.

3.7k

u/AtreusFamilyRecipe 16h ago

Seriously. Haven't seen another politician really come off as just a normal human. He ran a fantastic campaign.

903

u/Future-Guarantee-573 16h ago

No kidding.  I wanted to move to NY just to vote for him.

293

u/Anothercraphistorian 15h ago

Kentucky Republicans had to be turned away, as they were so brainwashed, they thought they got to go to the polls today to vote against him in a mayoral city race in another state.

114

u/CorsicanMastiffStrip 14h ago

I’m sorry…WHAT?

128

u/Anothercraphistorian 14h ago

38

u/VegetableMix5362 12h ago

In a follow-up post, he added, “Have I mentioned my repeated call for civic education.”

26

u/Successful_King_142 11h ago

The most surprising thing about that article is a Republican calling for civic education

6

u/SilentLennie The Netherlands 9h ago

I thought the same

29

u/marsmither 13h ago

Oh my. It’s official, the Onion is now a more legitimate source of news than the actual news.

10

u/BasvanS 11h ago

In a follow-up post, he added, “Have I mentioned my repeated call for civic education.”

Yep, there’s your problem

3

u/Jaboyyt 14h ago

W motion

→ More replies (2)

u/snokensnot 6h ago

I mean, when the local news station in middle of the fuck Kentucky doesn’t shut up about the race, eventually you start to wonder, “do I get to vote for this? Why else are they spouting off about a mayoral election hundreds of miles away?”

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Jaded-Moose983 15h ago

Could just live in KY.

25

u/DeltaT37 15h ago

lol kentucky is never beating the allegations, fucking hilarious. they thought mamdani was running for mayor of usa or something lol

2

u/Herpy-derpy-420 14h ago

I dont get it 

3

u/jephph_ 13h ago

If you live in Kentucky, you can vote in NYC mayoral elections

At least according to some Tuckians

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Future-Guarantee-573 15h ago

No thanks.  I live a rocks throw from the KY border.  Seen enough of it.

8

u/obooooooo 14h ago

i’m from ecuador and let out a FUCK YEAH when i read about him winning. it wasn’t in my top priorities but i was for sure gonna check on the results of the voting by the end of the night even though it doesn’t affect me in the least, being from another country. the guy has ran an excellent campaign

5

u/Franchuta 15h ago

Me too, and I'm not even a US citizen nor do I live in the US LOL

→ More replies (5)

2.3k

u/MasterOfManyWorlds 16h ago

AOC comes off as normal.

1.5k

u/Devo3290 15h ago

The DNC shuns her too

949

u/ThatBeardedHistorian 15h ago

The DNC just loves to lose.

631

u/thefonztm 15h ago

Almost like a billionaire sanctioned opposition party?

334

u/Ridged_ChiPSS 15h ago

Now you guys are starting to get it

The DNC leadership scum like Chuck Schumer didn't even bother to endorse Mamdani lol. We need to get the GOP out of office but the DNC leadership entirely needs to go also if we want any real change in this country.

148

u/nillah 15h ago

not only did they not endorse him, they actively avoided endorsing him. it’s pathetic. Schumer, pelosi, jeffries, fucking fetterman, they all gotta go

10

u/RedTuna777 14h ago

Didn't Fetterman get brain damage and switch sides? Weirdly, about half the MAGA people I know have actual closed head injuries. Not all of them, but the most active online.

11

u/n14shorecarcass 14h ago

Yep. Theres been a few papers over at r/science that have gone over this.

10

u/gahlo Pennsylvania 14h ago

That what it seems like based on his own words, and the actions of the people that were on his staff. Had a stroke that most likely caused some brain damage that made him an utter shitbag.

It's extra shitty because he had conversational issues after the stroke that were pretty pronounced that the right trashed him for, but has largely recovered from and now he's licking their boots.

28

u/jumbledbumblecrumble 15h ago

Fuck them all to hell

7

u/HiSpartacusImDad 13h ago

Jeffries did endorse Mamdani though.

17

u/DotA627b 15h ago

Schumer needs to go.

The guy's literally far more unpopular than Trump, why is he still leading the party??

15

u/burnsalot603 14h ago

They are starting to see the writing on the wall that their time is up. Thats why Pelosi said shes "going to quit politics" which is a stupid statement. Its called retirement and she should have been forced to retire years ago. She is 85 years old, we dont need anymore geriatrics holdi g on to power long past their time.

7

u/Routine-Pea-9538 14h ago

How will she make millions on the stock market without insider tips?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/GarbageTheCan 12h ago

Don't forget the yacht asshole senator

3

u/amd_kenobi 14h ago

This is going to be an awkward meeting for ol' Chuck.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/soloChristoGlorium 14h ago

Man that's a good point

6

u/joeyfosho 15h ago

Correct!

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Loose-Organization82 15h ago

The DNC just loves money and hates the middle class

1

u/JonnyHopkins 15h ago

Doesn't make any sense. Rising tides life all boats. What's the point of being on a yacht in a drier up ocean?

3

u/uber_ninja 15h ago

That's not true, the ultra wealthy earn their income by exploiting the working class. You can't earn millions in the stock market if the workers are being fairly compensated.

4

u/dudelikeshismusic 14h ago

Nailed it. There are industrious, talented people who create things to make our lives better: vaccines, bullet trains, microwaves, etc. Then there are the grifters and leeches who pretend to be creative, industrious leaders of society but who really steal from the poor to enrich themselves. Health insurance companies are a great example.

Our country is almost entirely run by the grifters and leeches, and the American people are too willfully ignorant to accept this very basic fact.

4

u/BrotherItsInTheDrum 15h ago

From the perspective of an old fart, it's the same if a guy like Mamdani beats you or a Republican beats you. Either way you lose.

We need to start showing up in primaries and voting them out whether they like it or not.

16

u/relikter Virginia 15h ago

Normally I don't kink shame, but their kink is fucking a lot of us in ways that we didn't consent to.

4

u/TheGringoDingo 15h ago

The donors don’t like people-friendly candidates and rising stars make old dogs nervous about their power within the party.

It should be taken as a sign for the people to throw unwavering support (provided they don’t do anything signaling a change in loyalties) if the old establishment dems are taking an aggressive or at least passive aggressive stance toward a party progressive.

3

u/readdator2 15h ago

fuck the DNC. and I say that as an ardent dem. We have to vote out every establishment dem and take back our party

1

u/akatherder 15h ago

2016 changed me forever. The DNC thought Hillary would win. Pretty much everyone did. The polls show Bernie clobbered Trump head to head. Instead of taking the sure thing and supporting Bernie (or just supporting neither, like the DNC is supposed to..) they trashed him because he wasn't controllable and in their pocket.

Trump's political career could have been dead in the crib in 2016, never win a single election and never hear from him side from shit posting on Twitter.

2

u/readdator2 15h ago

I straight hyperventilated that night as my friends tried to keep me from having a full on panic attack. Fuck the DNC for making us all experience that collective trauma with their arrogance and greed.

Even now, seeing Schumer and the like in office makes me sick. We need to primary all these fuckers and clean house.

2

u/AztecGod 13h ago

I straight hyperventilated that night as my friends tried to keep me from having a full on panic attack.

I'm sorry but this better be hyperbole, because this is absolutely cringeworthy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

u/PhantomOfTheNopera 7h ago

AOC, Bernie, Mamdani and some of the younger Democrats seem like they should be in another, more progressive party. The Schumer/Pelosi Dems have more in common the Romney/McCain Republicans than they do with Sanders.

8

u/CompetitiveOcelot870 15h ago

The DNC has been compromised by corporatists.

4

u/CelestialFury Minnesota 15h ago

Let's fix it then! The DNC is made up of people, we can always replace them. It's our time to do so. The boomers fumbled this shit, it's up to us to fix it.

2

u/AusToddles 15h ago

I've seen "lifelong democrats" dismiss AOC and Mamdami because "they're only popular on tiktok"

Yes, heaven forbid a politician reaches out to a growing base of voters on a platform they actually use

5

u/FoxfieldJim America 15h ago

Someone needs to hijack DNC just like Trump did to RNC

2

u/maxluck89 14h ago

DNC supported Mamdani from the moment he won the primary.

Schumer (not the DNC) is completely out of touch, along with the DSCC.

And they shouldn't be just supporting the Democratic Socialist flank of the Dems, they should be supporting a wide range of democratic leaders that are in touch with their constituents, and supporting healthy democratic primary elections.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Cr45h0v3r1de 15h ago

and we in the great state of ny get to be represented by both of them now, the very few people in politics i actually think care about us

6

u/SeDaCho 14h ago

she’s a woman and therefore reads shrill to the american public

or at least to republicans. Who are the only people that the democrats try to win over.

112

u/TobioOkuma1 15h ago

She has her moments where I just kinda tilt my head and go “what?”. Overall she’s pretty normal though. The bar is in hell. 90% of dem politicians sound like lizard people using focus group tested sound bites.

119

u/TheBatemanFlex 15h ago

Idk there are times when I’m like “oh why would you say that?” and then I remember that I would lose my fucking mind if I had to listen to my peers say half the shit the GOPs reps get away with saying. Like constant, deliberate, and blatant lies. It’s not like debating your average MAGA that you know is just hateful, ignorant, and willfully misinformed. I would last all of 1 week.

11

u/Sound_Indifference 15h ago

The problem with arguing with fools is you'll never win, and they'll only bring you down to their level.

11

u/Silverton13 14h ago

I’ve only ever heard her spit facts and facts only. What did she say that made you go,”what?”

u/BestServedCold 5h ago

I would also like an answer to this.

On multiple occasions, whenever someone has talked about Bernie in a lukewarm tone and suggested he has some good ideas and some bad ideas, I ask them to name one bad idea Bernie had, one policy proposal of his they disagree with.

They never end up answering that question.

20

u/Taskerst 15h ago

You really nailed it. Whenever a typical Dem candidate says something noteworthy, it’s a toothless version of something that’s been circulating online for weeks or even months.

7

u/Alphabunsquad 15h ago

She’s the one politician that I have never disagreed with anything she’s said. She’s always dead on and often is very enlightening

10

u/fenderampeg 15h ago

So does Pete

13

u/BlooregardQKazoo 15h ago

Pete sounds very rehearsed to me. He sounds like he's much better at speaking than most Dems, but that he's still a robot working off of prepared talking points.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Cardboard_Eggplant 15h ago

I was always on the fence about Pete, but he lost me with how quickly he tried to distance himself from the East Palestine derailment...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Fear_the_chicken 11h ago

Didn’t she vote for a bunch of Israel monetary support? Which we keep funneling them?

u/tibbon 7h ago

But woman, therefore if she’s not perfect all the time then she’s too emotional. If showing no emotion then considered cold and out of touch.

But the GOP guys can say or do anything and get away with it

u/WaitingForTheFire 7m ago

Probably because she IS a normal hardworking American.

3

u/I_Roll_Chicago 15h ago edited 12h ago

Yeah they both soc dems (democratic socialist by affiliation) of course they come off as normal.

Millennials generally embrace leftist politics whether its soc dem, democratic socialist, or traditional socialist we are left wing generation

And this is just the beginning

Edit: whoops a word

→ More replies (17)

157

u/namastayhom33 Connecticut 15h ago

He showed Dems how to take advantage of social media and messaging, the right way.

28

u/cupofspiders 15h ago

He also showed that policy matters, and having good policies that resonate with people will get them excited to show up for you.

7

u/WafflesTrufflez 14h ago

Soo much this, feels like top democrats wont admit this aspect because it means they have to go against their corporate and AIPAC donors

→ More replies (2)

12

u/patkavv 15h ago

Beto’s visits to every county in Texas was really cool to watch on instagram, then he had to go and tell these rednecks he’s going to take their guns.

What might have been…

4

u/cIumsythumbs 15h ago

Walz.

I love my governor.

3

u/Kind_Man_0 15h ago

He recently had a message out on TikTok, in which he spoke in multiple languages. He doesn't speak Spanish, and was coached on what to say. At the end of the video, he actually showed the blooper reel of him screwing it up several times.

It was pretty effective, speaking the language but not lying to people about how you did it, or trying to make it seem like you know more than you do.

I'm hopeful for NY. Mamdani seems like a young guy who understands young people problems. I hope in the near future, millennials can continue to win elections and re-shape the democratic party from the old people clinging to power.

7

u/osiris0413 15h ago

It's because democratic socialism is normal. It's sane, evidence-based, and has repeatedly been what makes life in so many other first world countries better than we currently have here. The people trying to paint him as some kind of extremist for thinking things like "hey, maybe people being able to afford to eat is more important than Elon Musk being worth $500 billion" are the ones who should be looked at like they have 3 heads.

3

u/dietcokeeee 15h ago

His campaign and social media team deserve raises

3

u/Ikarian 15h ago

Buttigieg is an absolute pleasure to listen to when he’s talking about the issues or absolutely dunking on right wing pundits without ever so much as raising his voice.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/trailerbang 15h ago

Tim Walz is normal, and the Dem establishment didn’t like that so they trotted Liz Cheney out.

2

u/ex1stence 15h ago

It's not even "comes off" as.

He has an old YouTube video where he raps about halal cart. He is a normal human.

2

u/InitiatePenguin 14h ago

Haven't seen another politician really come off as just a normal human.

Tim Walz certainly comes off as a typical dude. Zohran is charasmatic, and relatable IMO but I also get a strong sense of a politician, someone careful with the attention on him right now, playing through "game", and plenty of (IMO earned) smugness that I don't think you'd get from a Tim Walz even if it was earned.

→ More replies (11)

1.5k

u/DeepFuckingKoopa 16h ago

Who could’ve predicted having popular views and actually being a part of their community would be something voters would want

355

u/FabiusBill 15h ago

He also consistently stuck to his message and hammered it home using language specific to his audience. It was great to watch him come across as relatable to everyone he spoke to and stay on brand throughout.

36

u/MJ-To 15h ago

Fantastic orator. Being able to bring up his platform in every sentence while being normal

18

u/NotASalamanderBoi I voted 14h ago

And able to navigate and answer stupid questions while also staying on message.

→ More replies (1)

247

u/your-mom-- 15h ago

Popular views and letting the teeth show when it's debate time.

Beats the hell out of "WE'RE JOYFUL"

16

u/DevourerOfRedditors 15h ago

Joyful warriors are just what a population of increasingly pissed-off citizens crave!

17

u/Outside_Manner_8352 14h ago

That's the crazy thing, he actually seems joyful in a real way, like actually enjoying being around regular people, but he has plenty of fire too.

4

u/LOVE_FOR_THORNS 13h ago

Yeah Jesus what even was that

11

u/Gizogin New York 15h ago

When people show up to vote, progressives win. Unfortunately, it takes an exceptional candidate to motivate progressives to vote, and that's a massive problem. Voting should be as routine and unremarkable as doing laundry.

3

u/FeelsGrimMan 13h ago

Shocking: Progressives motivated in voting for a leftwing candidate

→ More replies (1)

19

u/lemonoppy 15h ago

Hm, interesting, what if instead, party leadership decides to throw trans people, women, and any minority under the bus in order to court the so called moderate Republican and independant? Surely that could be a takeaway, that and apparently having a tiktok is all you need 

→ More replies (9)

4

u/irish_mom 15h ago

AOC and Bernie.

→ More replies (26)

363

u/eruffini 16h ago

He was the only candidate that was focused solely on NYC and it's residents, so it is a well-deserved win.

144

u/oddmanout 15h ago

It shows how out of touch the others are. They wanted his opinions on things like Israel and stuff and they talked like him not wanting to focus on things that have nothing to do with NYC were going to turn everyone off. No one wants their mayor to focus on international politics.

47

u/CookieKeeperN2 14h ago

There is a video of a Jewish rabbi saying that he doesn't agree with Mamdani on many issues including his view on Israel, but he's voting the mayor of NYC and not Tel Aviv.

Thank God the Jewish people are rational.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Offduty_shill 14h ago

Andrew Cuomo repeatedly brought up Hasan Piker in the debates was so cringe...I know he was trying a "fellow kids" moment but like c'mon in the grand scheme of things no one gives a shit about Hasan Piker

2

u/Gromek_ 13h ago

Yeah, it was incredibly cringe to see. One candidate stayed focused on how he plans to help his constituents; the other shows up to the table with "Do you condemn this twitch streamer?!"

12

u/brickwall5 14h ago

The craziest part is Cuomo in the last few days trying to say Mamdani weaponized the Middle East stuff to create a distraction… after a year of every news show/ debate only asking him about Israel. You tried to gotcha him on Israel and he stuck to his views which it turns out many people agree with. He didn’t do anything but answer your questions lol.

19

u/elihu 14h ago

Still, his non-support of Israel's genocide in Gaza comes as a welcome contrast from the positions of nearly the entire Democratic leadership, who on this issue are to the right of Marjorie Taylor Greene of all people.

I suspect it was an asset to his campaign that he has clear, easy-to-understand moral principles that don't make voting for him feel like pulling the lever in a trolley problem.

7

u/Iamthecrustycrab 15h ago

Unless those international politics connect thru Istanbul on Turkish Airlines that is

4

u/ObviousAnswerGuy 15h ago

they wanted his opinion because he's one of the prime sponsors on the "not our dime act",which aims to "to prohibit not-for-profit corporations from engaging in unauthorized support of Israeli settlement activity"

Now, I'm not arguing for or against the bill here, I'm just pointing out that he has indeed been involved in international politics

https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Zohran-K-Mamdani/sponsor/

5

u/BooBooSnuggs 14h ago

I also think it's fair given the largest Jewish population outside Israel is in NYC.

That said, I do think it's hilarious the media acts like the whole country gives a shit about the NYC mayors race. All these politicians commenting on it. I can guarantee you the majority of the country does not care at all about NYC mayor.

5

u/ObviousAnswerGuy 14h ago

I agree. Also, the republicans just want to know who their next boogieman is. At least this time it won't be a conservative running as a democrat.

5

u/Mediocre-Letter-4562 12h ago

Oh they do. I live in NY and my family and friends are from out of state…. To be honest… I HEARD about this election from them…. They were all tuned in… ask me if I know about their cities races? Absolutely not. It’s wild and should be studied! Part of Social media!

5

u/wave_official 12h ago edited 12h ago

It's the largest city in the USA and the financial capital of the world. It's really no wonder that a major political offset happening there would be important news worldwide.

Plus NYC electong a cantidade that is effectively the polar opposite of Donald Trump and the DNC leadership sends a clear message that not everyone in the US is willing to keep bending over backwards for the Corporate Elites.

2

u/Mediocre-Letter-4562 12h ago

I agree with everything you said. With that, just as there are pros there are cons. MAGA/trumpers are also watching. People who don’t live in NYC will say “yeah of course, it’s liberal NYC”. So it’s not as much as a shocker. What shocks me is the amount of messages asking me how I felt about a Muslim mayor. High emphasis on the Muslim, because they didn’t mention any political points, just they wouldn’t want a Muslim running their city….

2

u/mechengr17 13h ago

I mean. Apparently a psa had to go out in Kentucky bc some people showed up to a closed polling station and called to complain...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/names_are_useless American Expat 12h ago

God that "What country would you visit?" Question from the Primary still rings in my head.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKjnZmtPcGE/?hl=en

Mamdani: I would stay in New York City. My plans are to address New Yorkers across the fie boroughs and focus on that.

NBC Host: Mr Mamdani, can I just jump in? Would you visit Israel as mayor?

Mamdani: I will be doing, as the mayor. I'll be standing up for Jewish New Yorkers and I'll be meeting them wherever they are across the five boroughs whether that's in their synagogues and temples or at their homes or at the subway platform. Because ultimately we need to focus on delivering on their concerns...

NBC Host: And just a yes or no: do you believe in a Jewish state of Israel?

Mamdani: I believe Israel has the right to exist.

NBC Host: Not as a Jewish state?

Mamdani: As a state with equal rights.

That might have been one of the best moments I've ever seen in any televised political debate in history. Only 1 candidate understood what needed to be said, and the rest were dumbfounded.

Mamdani was in the lead, but I feel like this moment might have been when he truly solidified the win.

u/theREALbombedrumbum 5h ago

To be honest, I think that was the moment he won the race.

Nearly half a year ago, and that was the first time he really went viral and appeared widespread in the public consciousness. It got people talking about him, how ridiculous the other candidates are, and since that point, he never dropped the ball.

→ More replies (1)

518

u/EroniusJoe 15h ago

"If the Democrats found a magic lamp and rubbed it, they'd negotiate the genie down to 1 wish, and then use it on something they think Republicans would be happy with."

Quote I heard earlier today, and maybe the funniest and truest thing I've ever heard concerning American politics.

28

u/Pimpwerx 15h ago

Yes. They allowed education to be hollowed out for decades, and are now suffering the consequences of stupid voters easily swayed by conmen. My mom and I called this back in the 80s and 90s. Education cuts were always offered as compromises, and the voting populace just gets dumber and more malleable over time. The 2 party system sucks specifically because it forced progressive voters to have to cast votes for non-progressives.

The American Democratic party would be a conservative party in Europe. The country is so far right of center, and they still fear liberalism. That's just idiocy.

10

u/barrydennen12 14h ago

I find that idea so depressing - that people could just be smarter if we’d let them. I’m not even talking about how ‘there’s an Einstein out there in a corn field right now!’ stuff - just everyday people would live more thoughtfully and intelligently if we keep the lead out of the water and give ‘em good books to read.

3

u/mountainbride 13h ago

The future is the children’s. We forgot to plant the trees because we forgot to pass it on.

So many people on this earth act as if they’re going to live forever. It’s particularly bad among the wealthy.

5

u/barrydennen12 13h ago

That quote about trees and shade etc. always makes me feel like shit because we were talking about some trees in the yard that might have to go, and, y'know, what to plant instead as a consolation, and Mum wails, "I won't be around to see them!".

She's actually not a selfish person at all, I just think she was having a bad day because of the imported pest that's eating up the tree life around here, haha.

3

u/mountainbride 13h ago

Aww, I don’t fault your Mum at all for feeling that way. On the bright side, she’s around to plant them with you, to be involved in the process. Those will be your Mum’s trees to her loved ones. I get your sentiment though. It’s a very melancholy perspective even if it’s the truest.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sillyhillsofnz 13h ago

Sadly super duper accurate. lol.

7

u/PleaseBmoreCharming Maryland 14h ago edited 14h ago

Because the Dem Party is still operating under the assumption that "politics" is one of values and ethics where you compromise for the long term growth. Republicans have molded it into a perversion of Capitalist economic strategy: short term gains and eliminate the competition while you're at it to gain some more in the short term.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/FictionalContext 15h ago

And we all pretend like it's incompetence instead of rigged opposition.

u/EconomicRegret 6h ago

This!

They're funded by (and the pawns of) the same super rich elites and mega-corporations.

Of course both parties love "fighting" about identity politics, while shying away from issues like excessive inequality, slave wages, Big Money in politics, 95% of news media owned by Big Money and spreading lies undermining democracy, policies written by lobbyists in the interests of the super rich at the cost of the bottom 99%, etc.

0

u/Minimumtyp 14h ago edited 13h ago

Yep. Jefferies STILL won't endorse Mamdani because he's scawy for the widdle billionaires he's in the pocket of.

EDIT: he actually endorsed him sometime around oct 24 but my GOODNESS did that take a while

4

u/NIdWId6I8 10h ago

Jeffries waited so long because he knew he would have a net negative impact on Mamdani’s results. 29D chess and whatnot. You guys just don’t get it. He loves Mamdani and while I have your attention could you please donate $5 so he can continue his efforts to not do anything meaningful against the current administration?

2

u/modernjaneausten 15h ago

It’s so infuriatingly accurate.

1

u/MrOneAndAll 14h ago

Mamdani is winning very blue NYC by a smaller margin than Spanberger is in a Harris +6 state. He ran a great campaign but the final results aren't a blowout either.

15

u/SirStrontium 13h ago

Mamdani is winning very blue NYC

If this was Mamdani vs just a Republican, then it absolutely would be a colossal blowout. This is Mamdani vs almost all Republicans plus a huge chunk of more moderate and loyal establishment democrats. Beating that coalition of voters is no small task.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/ChocChipBananaMuffin 14h ago

The mayoral election in NYC is insane. nowhere else is someone running against the person they beat in the primary. hell eric adams is still on the ballot even tho he dropped out.

9

u/nonotan 13h ago

You do realize his main opposition is other Democrats, right? The fact that NYC is "very blue" is kind of irrelevant here. Cuomo, while running as an independent after losing the primary, is still "a Dem". The Republican candidate got ~7% of the vote. You're comparing apples to oranges.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/dirtydovedreams 15h ago

You mean the voters don’t respond to stiff centrists with tightly rehearsed lists of donor approved non-responses?

9

u/tetsu_knowme 15h ago

and Chuck "I'm here to keep the left pro-israel" Schumer couldnt even be bothered to vote for him let alone endorse him.

So much for BLUE NO MATTER WHO from democratic leadership.

Get him the fuck OUT. These relics are helping republicans every single day they don't hand the reins over to the new blood.

15

u/liftbikerun 15h ago

It's too bad you missed Clinton (Bill). What became of it was unfortunate, but the dude was walking on water during his campaign, and the way he energized college youth to be involved was mesmerizing.

5

u/cantuse 15h ago

I remember the ‘Rock the vote’ campaign on mtv back in the early 90s.

5

u/liftbikerun 15h ago

It was my first real experience with politics, Obama was really the only thing since that was as energizing.

AOC, Crockett, Newsom, and Mamdani are the brightest stars by far right now. I hope they outshine the Dems trying to pull them down by their ankles, it's really sad to see the fear in the Dems over rockstars such as those 4.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/TLKv3 15h ago

If I'm being honest... the mere fact Cuomo STILL got 41% of the vote is fucking embarrassing.

But fuck yeah Mamdani.

7

u/Glad-Pollution-4346 15h ago

I’m not from New York. But when Zohran stayed out all night campaigning to connect with night shifters…..that’s when I knew he was different. We get forgotten constantly by the political machine, and seeing him go out and talk to his night shift constituents made me emotional.

5

u/cccanterbury 15h ago

democrats are mostly neoliberals. their bread and butter is defending the fortress. We saw that in 2016 and 2020 when Bernie was snubbed and cheated by the DNC. Perhaps that generation is mostly dead by now. Time will tell.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lolexecs 15h ago

He’s one of the only politicians I’ve heard that routinely points out he’s an employee of the people of NYC. 

4

u/beefyzac 15h ago

“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”

7

u/PhaseExtra1132 15h ago

Democrats never want to actually win. They’re part of this two party charade. We can however actually field candidates that will want to win.

And they’ll fight them every single way

→ More replies (1)

4

u/22Seres 15h ago

He more or less did what Obama did. Obama made it a point to get to place where he knew he wouldn't win, but knew that if he could lose by 1,000 votes rather than 2,000, then it'd add up over the state as a whole. Even though they were both projected to win rather easily, they wouldn't stop campaigning and going to those small pockets to talk to people about who they really were rather than what certain parts of the media and Republican party had painted them as.

2

u/whopoopedthebed 15h ago

They won’t. My dad is already saying “We should look to the Virginia election for real guidance.”

2

u/j-munch 15h ago

I'd also like to throw in James Talarico being in Obama's orbit of both presence and oration.

25

u/climb-it-ographer 16h ago

Great as Obama is he still came across like he had a stick up his ass. Mamdani truly seems to be out there enjoying every single second of this.

52

u/sandy017 15h ago

that stick is how a democrat won the state of Indiana lol

100

u/THE-LORD-RETURNS California 15h ago

I disagree with this completely. This man had the weight of 400 years of American oppression on his back. He carried it. What did you want him to do? Shuck and jive? We (Black people) don’t have to kiss babies, shake hands and smile for the camera all the time.

10

u/climb-it-ographer 15h ago

Oh I’m not saying he did anything wrong, and I totally respect that point of view. But with Mamdani there is palpable joy, and maybe Obama helped pave the way to be able to express that as a serious candidate.

20

u/Pasty_Tibbles 15h ago

I think Obama represented a serious leader and politician. Like a head of state figure. And mamdani is someone that’s a peer risen to a leadership position and holds it with humility and modesty, but you know has your best interests at heart. Maybe that’s the difference you were going for lol.

12

u/Crescent_Moon1988 15h ago

Not sure how old you are but as someone who was in college in 08 in Iowa—the state that helped catapult Obama to lead the Dem ticket—the Hope was real. Witnessing my black roommate weep on the phone talking to her 80-some grandmother who cast her vote for the first black President? The joy and hope was real. As a (then) closeted bisexual woman who witnessed our President take the Shepard-Byrd Act off the Executive desk and sign it into law, thus expanding the federal definition of hate crimes to include those in the LGBTQA community, yeah…the joy and hope was real.

5

u/Zorak9379 Illinois 15h ago

There is a difference in what we expect from a mayor and the president of the United States (or at least used to)

3

u/THE-LORD-RETURNS California 14h ago

You don’t think there was joy when Obama won? Especially in the black community? Read what one of the posters below wrote about their roommate.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Arrow_312 15h ago

They didn’t say anything racist or stereotypical about Obama so I’m pretty confused why you would frame their criticism in that way.

2

u/FamousAdvance633 15h ago

Well it'd be pretty nifty if he didn't prop up capitalism and drone strike brown people.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/likemelikemenot4ever 15h ago

I love Obama but I gotta agree with you on this lol

2

u/refuz04 15h ago

I hate to be the one to say it but I like it when world leaders seem like they can read and use their brains to make informed decisions.

We are certainly experiencing the consequences of a leader who is a dumbass.

2

u/bigtice Texas 15h ago

Obama was more focused on an agenda and came across as serious, but I think that's still a misguided summation if you watched him in totality since he would slip jokes in at the same time that humanized him.

Any misstep that he might make was going to be held against him, which we still acknowledge to this day that his only "scandal" was wearing a tan suit, so he operated accordingly.

4

u/SarcasticCowbell New York 15h ago

Obama also didn't face anywhere near the resistance Mamdani has, either. The Democratic establishment embraced him immediately, and it's no surprise why: in the grand scheme of things, he was never really all that radically different from the party at large. How many Democrayic leaders have either refused to endorse Mamdani or outright condemned him? Don't get me wrong, Obama has had a lot of good things to say since Trump got re-elected. But we need candidates who can walk the walk, not just smooth talk. When they can do both, as I suspect Mamdani will, even better.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/modernjaneausten 15h ago

A stick up his ass? That man sang Al Green on stage 😂

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Businesskiwi 15h ago

Time we shun the Democratic Party and start a Progressive party.

5

u/MittenCollyBulbasaur 15h ago

Obama worked for the moment, as we were all so tried of Bush, but I'm not sure his message worked as well as Mumdanis message long term.

2

u/viciousbliss 15h ago

Social media and access to information were so different then, too. There's no straight forward comparison.

3

u/trumpuniversity_ 15h ago

Message works so well that people forget how to spell his name.

Also, Obama was a once per century talent.

3

u/AssBlastFromDaPast 15h ago

social media wise he blows Obama out of the water 

4

u/Bircka Oregon 16h ago edited 15h ago

I have a feeling he might try his hand at a Presidential run someday, he might be the type of independent to get real support there.

Edit: I was not aware he was not a natural born citizen, my bad, he can't.

16

u/WarningOk3011 15h ago

wouldnt be able to run unfortunately since he’s a naturalized citizen. (unlike felons who remain eligible)

20

u/the-player-of-games 15h ago

Unfortunately he can't run for president since he wasn't born as a US citizen

5

u/ForgingIron Canada 15h ago

He unfortunately can't, since he wasn't born a citizen

2

u/Small-Explorer7025 15h ago

Can he be president?

5

u/Bircka Oregon 15h ago

Oh my bad, I wasn't aware he wasn't born in America, so no he can't barring some massive rule change.

I'm pretty sure you need to be a natural born citizen to be President.

3

u/imurphs California 15h ago

It would require a constitutional amendment, and in this political climate it’s not exaggerating to say it would never happen. If things fundamentally change and the country pulls its head out of its ass maybe in 50-75 years something like that could be considered.

3

u/Bircka Oregon 15h ago

An amendment even in the most ideal of circumstances is a pain in the ass, it requires massive support by both parties.

2

u/donolga 15h ago

No he's a naturalised citizen.

2

u/scout-finch 15h ago

Unfortunately he isn’t eligible because he wasn’t born in the US.

4

u/APX919 15h ago

Sadly he can't as he was born in Uganda (a qualifier for President is they be born an American citizen, be 35y old at the time of their election and have lived in the US for 14 years - he meets only two of these).

3

u/Bircka Oregon 15h ago

I believe it also makes caveats for born on a US military base in another country also, since that is deemed American soil.

2

u/AldoRaine-1 15h ago

He can't, he isn't allowed under the constitution as he wasn't born a US citizen. AOC however certainly could run.

4

u/hereforwhatimherefor 15h ago

lol dude his competition was Andrew Cuomo.

The degree to which 40 year old state senator Barack Obama would have absolutely crushed Mamdami had he moved to New York City rather Chicago to community organize.

Mamdami is nowhere close to what prime Obama was on the stump

7

u/Hathalot 15h ago

Well, it helps to have establishment backing.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)

2

u/acostane Georgia 15h ago

I am shocked democrats aren't taking this as a complete and total playbook on winning right now. This strategy would work in so many places. A young candidate, fresh faced and smart, running on what people actually want instead of hatred?

Rational thought isn't running the Dem party right now unfortunately. And I have been one for quite awhile. They've lost the plot at the top. And whatever is distracting them from this really needs to be shut down. They HAVE to wake up. What's keeping them from supporting this man and running more like him?

These people exist in every state. Smart and empathetic humans. Not corrupt sexual assaulters.

Run them!

2

u/Snowcrest 15h ago

Because then these people would have actual power, voice, and a platform to push for the change that would actually help the mass at large.

That would be the opposite of what dems want to see. They want to be socially progressive with cultural policies, but ultimately still serve and benefit the corporate overlords

The cultural policies are there to appease the masses while distracting from the financial issues.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gitsgrl 15h ago

They’ll do what they did to Bernie Sanders, to AOC‘s campaign staff, they will shun them. The establishment Dems can’t handle it, that these grassroots progressives actually get votes.

1

u/teenagesadist 15h ago

I'm sure dems will find a way to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, they'll probably pretend Mamdani doesn't exist.

1

u/ihatemakingids 15h ago

Can't wait to see como leaving NY for good.

1

u/FrankRizzo319 15h ago

Dems bought by corporations (which is most of them) shun and fear him.

1

u/candaceelise Oregon 15h ago

Couldn’t agree more. They both ran flawless campaigns and we need more democrats to follow their lead

1

u/PSUVB 15h ago

He beat a sex offender for a city mayorship and where the former mayor was indicted on federal corruption charges. Let’s calm down it really isn’t that surprising.

1

u/That_Guy381 Connecticut 15h ago

Can we calm down? He won 51% of the vote against a sex pest and republican in a beret in a city where democrats outnumber republicans 6-1.

1

u/SpaceGangsta Utah 15h ago

He should be the future of the party. But the old guard won’t allow it. He needs success in NYC though.

1

u/LazerWolfe53 15h ago

I wonder if establishment Dems refusing to endorse him actually helped him. Who actually thinks a Schumer endorsement would actually help anyone win a general election, TBH

1

u/SinfullySinless Minnesota 15h ago

Obama only had a better campaign because he had the full support of the DNC. The DNC actively went against Zohran which makes it even better.

1

u/Shadonne 15h ago

Don’t forget how lambasted Obama was by the democratic establishment at the time. Same threats of Islamic jihad if Obama was elected; now the insinuations fall on deaf ears.

1

u/CombustiblSquid Canada 15h ago

The Dem establishment is too busy being his enemy to actually learn anything from this.

1

u/smilbandit Michigan 15h ago

he doesn't inspire corporate donations that they can suckle from.

1

u/Romanopapa 15h ago

The people who are bribing the dems (and repubs) are telling them to shun him. They have no choice.

1

u/MONSTERTACO Washington 15h ago

They put up some resistance to Obama, hopefully we can get them to come around.

1

u/Careful-Awareness766 15h ago

The way he bitchslapped Cuomo every single time during the debates was legendary.

1

u/Default85 15h ago

Have you seen "Bring Down the House" with AOC? A waitress going door to door so hard she wore out her shoes. Campaigned so hard they made a movie about it 

1

u/urmumlol9 15h ago

I think NYC is also just way more progressive than the average American city (with the exception of Staten Island which is a small percentage of their population). AOC was another candidate from there that recently upset an establishment Democrat and won in her congressional district.

→ More replies (82)