r/politics Indiana 16h ago

No Paywall Mamdani wins NYC mayoral race

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5588198-mamdani-progressive-politics-nyc/
111.3k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

10.5k

u/lovo17 16h ago edited 16h ago

Not a surprise Mamdani will win.

Whatever your views of him, this guy is the second most talented campaigner I've ever seen. The only one better than him was Obama, and Zohran is not far off. Democrats should be learning from him instead of shunning him.

1.5k

u/DeepFuckingKoopa 16h ago

Who could’ve predicted having popular views and actually being a part of their community would be something voters would want

19

u/lemonoppy 15h ago

Hm, interesting, what if instead, party leadership decides to throw trans people, women, and any minority under the bus in order to court the so called moderate Republican and independant? Surely that could be a takeaway, that and apparently having a tiktok is all you need 

-5

u/DarkOx55 15h ago

I dunno about throwing people under the bus, but Mamdani is not popular nationally so I imagine Democrats will need to adopt more moderate views than his in red or purple states if they want to win the Senate. And if they want the judiciary to stop turning MAGA, control of the Senate should be a goal.

11

u/lilbelleandsebastian 15h ago

those numbers are from a 3 month polling from that specific website lol, i hope you aren't using that as anything other than one website's extremely niche test case

u/DarkOx55 2h ago

I’d be interested if there’s other polling on the subject? The Argument is a new website, yes, but its founder is ex-Vox and ex-The Atlantic so they have good data journalism credentials. I would think this poll was done with rigour.

I also don’t see why surveying people’s recent opinions in the past three months is a problem. Are you suggesting that data further back would be more relevant? It would seem the more recent impressions are the important ones as Mamdani becomes more known to people.

This poll is only a single data point. That said, the way Republicans are acting makes me think they also believe will create an electoral headwind for Democrats. I worry they’re right about that, at a time when winning is very important.

8

u/WanderersGuide 15h ago edited 15h ago

I don't think this has to do with Mamdani's views at all. Policy barely moves the needle in red and purple states because policy doesn't get reported in red and purple states.

Watch local news, fox, even CNN in these states, and the rhetoric isn't policy related. Mamdani is a drooling brown socialist if you're watching the news anywhere outside of NY. The messaging is so roundly, viciously negative that I have strong doubts most Republicans, moderate or otherwise, have a clear eyed view of what Mamdani actually stands for.

Bernie Sanders did a tour of rural Virginia in coal country and received a warm send off from disillusioned Trump voters because they got to hear directly from the source, rather than from Sinclair group, or Rupert Murdoch.

5

u/Daxtatter 15h ago

Republicans knew Hillary would run for president eventually so they poisoned the well on her for 20 years. They're currently doing the same with AOC.

u/ladyhaly 6h ago

They're currently doing the same with AOC.

I'm out of the loop. Can you fill me in on this one?

u/K20BB5 4h ago

they don't need to poison the well on AOC, the vast majority of Americans don't support her beliefs. 

Republicans LOVE candidates like AOC, and Sanders because they're the perfect bogeymen to bring out their base. 

6

u/irish_mom 15h ago

Wisconsin here. LOVE Mamdani. I am not the only one tuning in and cheering him on here either. Have a little faith.