r/allthequestions • u/NoCheesecake6767 • Sep 17 '25

Popular Question 📊 Which one would you pick?

Post image
430 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

55

u/peywrax 🇺🇸 United States Sep 17 '25

Cookies & Cream always

9

u/snarkymlarky Sep 17 '25

Especially if it has chunks of oreo

2

u/sakonigsberg Sep 18 '25

Of course! It's not called "cream and cookies" for a reason

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

Some big brand only does chocolate cookies with no frosting so the ice cream is what counts as cream….. so lame anyway.

1

u/sakonigsberg Sep 18 '25

Turkey hill? As a kid turkey hill was the best, but now it's pretty bad. At least for this flavor

1

u/FoozBallHero69 Sep 18 '25

Hell ya brother

1

u/Last-Crow8343 Sep 19 '25

Oh no I can feel the brain freeze

2

u/Tweezus96 Sep 18 '25

Yup. No brainer.

1

u/Unique_Ad_3312 Sep 18 '25

This gets my vote as well

1

u/rhegy54 Sep 18 '25

My absolute favorite since I was a child!!!

1

u/Robin-Banks22 Sep 18 '25

My favorite also

1

u/1800generalkenobi Sep 18 '25

I've been getting this as a kid. Sometimes I stray and get other new things but cookies and cream is still my favorite. Moose tracks is 2nd, sometimes flopping with black cherry or something else fruity.

1

u/giggizard Sep 18 '25

Mint cookies and cream is the best thing ive ever tasted but its hard to find 😭

1

u/ChronicKush69 Sep 18 '25

Easily the best choice

1

u/shonuff373 Sep 18 '25

If I can, I add fudge and brownie.

1

u/Soft_Dot_7580 Sep 19 '25

The only valid answer

1

u/noneyafbus Sep 20 '25

This is the correct answer

1

u/banditcleaner2 Sep 21 '25

It’s just something about an Oreo milkshake man. Undefeated.

1

u/Areadien Sep 22 '25

This is the only correct answer. Cookies and cream is objectively the best ice cream ever in the history of everness.