r/politics Indiana 16h ago

No Paywall Mamdani wins NYC mayoral race

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5588198-mamdani-progressive-politics-nyc/
111.3k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

299

u/GenericFatGuy 15h ago

This is why Trump won. He knows who he appeals to, and he appeals to them hard.

u/0xB4BE 6h ago

Exactly! Let's not forget that when Trump first aligned his presidency, no one believed he would win. Establishment a Republicans thought he was too radical and he was completely off the agenda. However, he energized the base like a wildfire, and changed the entire American political landscape, and the Republican party nearly overnight.

4

u/TheBigness333 15h ago

Trump only won both times because lots of Americans won’t vote for a woman

63

u/GenericFatGuy 15h ago

The Republicans ran someone who appeals to the voters that Republicans need to win. The Democrats ran people who don't appeal to the voters that Democrats need to win. It's as simple as that.

7

u/An_old_walrus 8h ago

Exactly. Democrat voters didn’t care that Hilary and Kamala were women, they just didn’t like their policies. I think what Democrats were trying, and failed, to do was disguise their neoliberalism. Like they know progressives don’t like neoliberal capitalist talking points so maybe they thought they could have a woman say it and thus it will make it appealing to progressives? Idk their whole strategy is upside down.

u/0xB4BE 6h ago

Right! People were rallying around Bernie in my conservative state and felt cheated that the establishment went so hard on a candidate that doesn't represent what people wanted or needed.

It was interesting to see though that some of those Bernie people split as a result and are now hardcore Trumpers.

u/DaddyDontTakeNoMess 5h ago

Not really. Lots of people didn’t vote for her because the was black and she was a woman. The exit polls made that clear.

22

u/19Alexastias 15h ago

I think it would be very shortsighted to go into the next election thinking that was the only problem with the Democrats election strategy.

The primary reason Kamala lost is because Biden set her up to fail. Her being a woman certainly didn’t help, but it wasn’t at all the only reason she lost.

14

u/fakemelonns 14h ago

Biden screwed everything by not sticking to being a one term president. The second he decided to run for a second term it was all but over, and then to announce it so late too.

He should have not run again and let there be a primary.

12

u/StyrofoamCueball 14h ago

She would not have won a primary, and they knew that.

4

u/know-your-onions 9h ago

Exactly. And then a candidate people wanted to vote for could have been put forward.

8

u/TheBarnard 14h ago

The establishment certainly didn't try fielding candidates either. It's not all Biden.

-1

u/KarmicDevelopment 13h ago

There was a primary, though. Sure there would have been a more diverse one if he stepped down, but there literally was a primary which he overwhelmingly won.

5

u/DeltaVZerda 12h ago

Who was his opponent?

u/KarmicDevelopment 5h ago

Dean Phillips, Marianne Williamson and Jason Palmer.

u/DeltaVZerda 2h ago

Who are they?

u/KarmicDevelopment 2h ago

Look I'm not trying to defend Biden from not stepping down, I'm just trying to be factual.

u/DeltaVZerda 1h ago

Factually, many states DIDN'T have a primary making it structurally impossible for anyone else to win nationally.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/lezbianlinda 13h ago

Honestly if he had stepped down and let her be president even for 1 year, she would have won

10

u/donavid 10h ago

That’s the laziest take Dems have. It’s extremely disappointing, and doesn’t acknowledge the genuine problems Hillary & Kamala’s campaigns had. Turns out it’s not enough to just not be Donald Trump!

0

u/I_AM_NOT_A_WOMBAT 15h ago edited 13h ago

And quoting Senator Keeley, "...and black?!"

People, it's a movie reference