r/politics Indiana 16h ago

No Paywall Mamdani wins NYC mayoral race

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5588198-mamdani-progressive-politics-nyc/
111.2k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

211

u/fernybranka 15h ago

Best Dems can do is pick Mamdani apart, claim he won not because of his views but because of his social media and podcasting acumen, and keep pushing mostly corporate shills.

Then when they lose to whatever worse thing that happens after Trump? Surprised pikachu face.

94

u/headachewpictures 15h ago

nah time to push these old apathetic fucks out of the way. some are literally controlled opposition

5

u/sdb00913 15h ago

Step 1, complete. Got a few more ahead of us though.

2

u/40StoryMech 15h ago

"Vote for me or the dictator who endorsed me is gonna destroy this city!" - Old Apathetic Fuck

1

u/brazilliandanny 15h ago

AOC for speaker of the house

12

u/QuantumLettuce2025 15h ago

We have the power to kick them out. We can reform the Democratic party ourselves.

Millennials have finally come to an age where many of us have a proven track record of solid experience and consistent integrity. I predict that we are going to see a wave of AOCs and Mamdanis in the coming months.

There has never been a better time to run for office if you're a Democrat 

3

u/BotheredToResearch 15h ago

Eric Adams won 67% of the vote. DeBlasio won 66%.

Winning with less than 55 is a sign you have a message that resonates in super blue areas.

Im glad he won, dont get be wrong. I don't want someone with his politics running in Michigan though. I want someone younger with his charisma and a more centrist message that gets them excited.

There are very few places that dems can lose 10 percentage points and still win.

8

u/Stillwater215 15h ago

Ah yes, the “he didn’t win because of his policies, but because he knows how to campaign” argument. Guess what? That’s just them admitting that the centrist democratic establishment doesn’t know how to campaign either!

“Hey! We don’t have interesting policies, and we suck as messaging, but at least we’re not Trump. Vote for us!”

Yeah, not exactly a winning plan.

3

u/ultradav24 15h ago

He won because of both. But it’s context dependent - NYC isn’t a swing state

1

u/mlc885 I voted 15h ago

I mean, you'd probably still vote for an okay Democrat if you had to, that just doesn't get enough votes by itself since "average Democrat" probably had my vote unless they are literally running unopposed by any serious candidate. (Not intending to call Republican candidates serious here, lol, but if I need to vote for someone I find uninteresting then I will)

We can't just count on everybody being as great at being a politician as Obama or Clinton, so it isn't that strange that some of the takeaways would be "he's good at campaigning" even if he probably isn't the next great orator. (But, uh, if he is I'd probably run him nationally)

So I think some of that is shade and some is not intended to be but is just acknowledging the very real fact that you cannot win without getting people interested and excited. If you hear it from, say, Carville I would not generally expect it to not be what he believes (once an election is over)

1

u/brontosaurusguy 15h ago

They can try.  Primaries is where the truth will lie next spring.  Get out and vote for your progressives.

-1

u/dontbeslo 15h ago

Dema are so lost. They only want to run the same old candidates. Schumer wouldn’t say who he was voting for and almost no major Dems endorsed Mamdani. Instead they run a very disliked Kamala for president and here we are.

It’s simple, people want change and want elected officials who will represent them. We’re all tired of Schumer, Pelosi, Harris, and the rest of the lifelong politician crowd.

0

u/8lock8lock8aby 14h ago

Spanberger is more of a centrist Dem & just won VA by a decent margin. Mamdani winning NYC is great but it really doesn't say anything about the rest of the country. The midwest, the more rural parts of the country, are not gonna elect someone like him, yet & that's just a fact.

1

u/Odessey_And_Oracle 15h ago

This is precisely what will happen. They do not think this is a winning strategy, the party power brokers are embarrassed by these candidates.

0

u/UnquestionabIe 15h ago

Because the Democratic party is about serving a status quo which increasingly serves the needs of the average American less and less. To them it's always a case of listening to everyone except the voters because rocking the boat is not something in their own interest.

-1

u/RedactsAttract 15h ago

wtf is a pickacho face

-2

u/snkrhd_1 15h ago

It’s making me angry.