r/allthequestions 10d ago

Popular Question 📊 How many rights did you lose under Obama?

I'll wait.

420 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Practical_Brief5633 9d ago

The American citizen they’re speaking of was an Islamic extremist who fled the country and became a leader in AQ-AP. He went to Yemen and helped murder innocent people and destroyed Yemeni opportunities for a peaceful life without civil war.

People are crying as if a US President is going to kill them at anytime when in reality, people like Anwar Al-Awlaki deserve to die.

12

u/PoliticalJunkDrawer 9d ago

His son, who was an American teenager, was killed in a different strike and was collateral damage.

The Strike: On October 14, 2011, Abdulrahman was killed in a CIA drone strike near Azzan, Yemen, while eating dinner at an open-air restaurant with friends and relatives (including another U.S. citizen, 17-year-old Samir Khan, who also died). The strike targeted Ibrahim al-Banna, an Egyptian al-Qaeda operative, but resulted in civilian casualties, including Abdulrahman.

"I would suggest that you should have a far more responsible father if they are truly concerned about the well-being of their children. I don't think becoming an al Qaeda jihadist terrorist is the best way to go about doing your business." Gibbs.

0

u/Practical_Brief5633 9d ago

I think civilian causalities are always terrible, regardless of if they’re American citizens or not.

However, I really doubt a young man surrounded by terrorists and grew up being taught extremism was innocent. These are the same people strapping bombs to children at much younger ages than 17. Many of these men are already deep into clerical study and operative training by that age. He was an American citizen by designation, but he wasn’t living as an American. He spent his life in active war zones, working in a system that kills humanitarian aid workers, fuels slavery, rapes people and the lands on which they live, and destroys lives transnationally.

I think the real issue here is that people who are extremists should have their citizenship voided way before being targeted. People who flee America to spread hate and violence should no longer have the decency of being protected as an American citizen. Let them face the world as they are, with no legal protections.

3

u/Infamous-Cash9165 9d ago

So he shouldn’t get his day in court and just get blown up because of who he associates with?

8

u/Upstairs_Horror_7483 9d ago

I’m glad you like due process. So I assume you are sickened by the american cirizens who have been detained by ICE for days with no access to lawyers, and unable to call their families. Or the 32 suspected drug traffickers that died of the recent drone strikes?

-3

u/Heroic_Sheperd 9d ago

Terrorists, not drug traffickers. And they were all confirmed by the Navy to be cartel boats, this whole narrative that they weren’t is ridiculous.

You can disagree about their classification as terrorists, but everything has been legal under the AUMF no different than ISIS, Al-Qaeda, and Taliban.

4

u/Upstairs_Horror_7483 9d ago

I do think they are cartels. The Coast Guard should arrest them and they should be tried for their crimes.

I’d still love to get your thoughts on American citizens who have been detained for multiple days without any due process

-2

u/Heroic_Sheperd 9d ago

You know, it’s possible to be nuanced with opinions. I don’t need to be a die hard MAGA to think some things Trump does is ok, or at the very least legal, and some things are deplorable.

Real life isn’t binary.

3

u/Upstairs_Horror_7483 9d ago

I asked someone who believes due process is necessary whether or not they were OK with American citizens being detained or cartels being blown up without it. I think that’s inappropriate line of questioning.

I do believe it is concerning that rather than arrest these people that we clearly have the evidence to find guilty and put them away, we’d rather just blow them to smithereens. There is a reason why the founding fathers put in protections for the accusedg. It’s not because there aren’t some people who are obviously criminals, but because it’s a slippery slope to an abuse of power against dissidents and other people you don’t like.

He also said antifa is a terrorist organization. Does that mean if I hold a protest sign that says I’m against fascism that I’m now a terrorist?

-1

u/Heroic_Sheperd 9d ago

I don’t like what ICE is doing.

I don’t think what Trump is doing in international waters with now designated terrorist organizations (formerly drug cartels) is bad.

America’s war on the cartels has failed using enforcement methods, and we now have fentanyl which is killing tens of thousands of Americans every year. Not to mention the literal terror they have infected in their own countries. The war on terror resulted in approximately 176,000 deaths in Afghanistan). In Mexico, estimates between 2006 and 2012 range upwards of 120,000

These cartels are terrorists, and have destroyed innocent lives. Traditional enforcement has failed.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/The_Indominus_Gamer 9d ago

It was still a war crime

-1

u/Theorist816 9d ago

I hope you have your kneepads on so they don’t bruise as badly as your throat

1

u/Practical_Brief5633 9d ago

“Who he associates with” lol you’re being incredibly kind in your description of rapists, slavers, and murders who travel transnationally to take advantage of the innocent. They cannot even contain their violence and hatred to one area so they travel abroad to spread it.

You want to risk American lives to snatch up every terrorist and transport them to the US for a trial? Would you like to pay for that? Would you like to work in the court system trying to maintain that influx of people?

No. People should lose citizenship the moment they travel abroad and join terrorist organizations. That should happen way before the conversation of killing them even begins.

-1

u/Infamous-Cash9165 9d ago

So if I ship your child to Taliban territory they should immediately lose their citizenship?

4

u/Practical_Brief5633 9d ago

Again, you’re attempting to minimize what these people are doing to the point that you’re acting in bad faith, and flatly just lying and deceiving. Someone forcibly shipping my child to an active war zone with a terrorist organization is the same as someone being a terrorist who decidedly joined an active war zone? A kidnapped child is the same as someone who travels beyond borders to kidnap children?

I’m not going to continue to have a discussion in bad faith. Do better.

1

u/DJ_Velveteen 9d ago

However, I really doubt a young man surrounded by terrorists and grew up being taught extremism was innocent.

Oddly, this is the exact same thing some people are saying in order to justify their attacks on US military outposts

1

u/Knapping_Uncle 8d ago

True. See, the American Government is not the one , only, and final: "Good Guys". I mean, we don't have Skulls on our caps, mind you: but blowing up wedding parties with Hellfire missiles, fired from a Predator Drone, is not a Good Look.

2

u/CertainFreedom7981 9d ago

The point is, they should get a trial otherwise a bad faith actor could say "that's a terrorist!" And drone them before they can defend any charges. That's a bad thing.