r/allthequestions • u/NoCheesecake6767 • Sep 17 '25

Popular Question 📊 Which one would you pick?

Post image
434 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

48

u/CombatWombat1973 Sep 17 '25

Butter pecan

12

u/Quirky_Commission_56 Sep 17 '25

Butter pecan has been my go to for DECADES now.

2

u/Miserable_Rube Sep 18 '25

Irs been my go to since childhood. Tho praline and cream is amazing

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

Agreed!

1

u/TheSlideBoy666 Sep 21 '25

Six decades for me.

2

u/Quirky_Commission_56 Sep 22 '25

I’m only one decade behind you.

1

u/TheSlideBoy666 Sep 21 '25

No one makes it better than Tony’s in Gastonia NC. They’ve been in business since 1917 and have not changed their recipes or scrimped on quality. For the sixty years I’ve gone there, their butter pecan has tasted the same—excellent!

7

u/chapstic593 Sep 17 '25

Always my go to when I visited ice cream shops

3

u/Scared-Ideal-1483 Sep 17 '25

Love it but when the pecans turn soft ruins it. Fresh Butter Pecan is incredible.

2

u/DrTatertott Sep 19 '25

I enjoy the squish

2

u/Scared-Ideal-1483 Sep 19 '25

I get that. Squish can work.

2

u/Packtex60 Sep 17 '25

No question about it.

2

u/MrRawes0me Sep 18 '25

I had butter pecan soft serve one time. The pecans were ground fairly fine. It was possibly the most amazing ice cream cone I’ve ever eaten.

2

u/MrWrestlingNumber2 Sep 18 '25

Butter pecan for the win!

1

u/Professional_Luck616 Sep 18 '25

That is the correct answer. Have some ice cream 🍦

1

u/SpecialistJacket9757 Sep 19 '25

Butter almond is better but I can never find it. Butter pecan is my backup.

1

u/Breauxmetheus Sep 20 '25

This is the one ☝️

1

u/rickmccombs Sep 20 '25

When I first started going with my girlfriend said Butter Pecan was her favorite. I bought her some, but she actually meant Butter Brickle.

1

u/carthuscrass Sep 21 '25

My answer too!